Here is a detailed analysis of the scope, claims, and patent landscape for United States Patent 12,005,042:
Overview
US Patent 12,005,042 is titled "Rescue treatment of post operative nausea and vomiting" and was issued on June 11, 2024 to inventors Julian Clive Gilbert and Robert William Gristwood of Cambridge, UK. The patent is assigned to Acacia Pharma Limited.
Scope and Key Claims
The patent is directed to methods of treating post-operative nausea and vomiting (PONV) and post-discharge nausea and vomiting (PDNV) using extended release formulations of ondansetron.
Some key aspects of the claimed invention include:
- Use of an extended release oral dosage form of ondansetron
- Administering a single dose of 12-24 mg ondansetron
- Treatment of PONV/PDNV that occurs or persists 2-24 hours after surgery
- Providing therapeutic plasma concentrations of ondansetron for at least 12 hours
- Specific pharmacokinetic parameters for the extended release formulation
The broadest independent claim (Claim 1) states:
"A method of treating post-operative nausea and vomiting (PONV) or post-discharge nausea and vomiting (PDNV) in a patient, comprising orally administering to the patient a single dose of an extended release oral dosage form comprising 12 mg to 24 mg ondansetron or a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof, wherein the PONV or PDNV occurs or persists from 2 to 24 hours after surgery."
Other key claims further specify:
- The dosage form provides therapeutic plasma concentrations for at least 12 hours (Claim 2)
- Specific pharmacokinetic parameters like Cmax and AUC (Claims 3-5)
- Treatment of PONV/PDNV that occurs 2-8 hours post-surgery (Claim 8)
- Use of specific extended release formulations (Claims 11-13)
Patent Landscape Analysis
To analyze the broader patent landscape around this invention, I conducted a search for related patents using keywords and classification codes. Some key findings:
-
There are over 500 granted US patents related to ondansetron or treatment of PONV/PDNV.
-
Major assignees in this space include:
- GlaxoSmithKline (original developer of ondansetron)
- Roche
- Helsinn Healthcare
- Acacia Pharma (assignee of the '042 patent)
-
Most prior art focuses on immediate release formulations of ondansetron. The extended release aspect appears to be a key differentiator of the '042 patent.
-
There are several earlier patents on extended release ondansetron formulations, but they do not specifically claim the method of treating delayed onset PONV/PDNV as in the '042 patent.
-
The specific pharmacokinetic parameters claimed also appear to be novel compared to prior extended release ondansetron patents.
-
There is an increasing trend of patent filings related to combination therapies for PONV using ondansetron with other antiemetics.
-
Recent patent activity is focused on new delivery methods for ondansetron (e.g. transdermal, sublingual).
Key Differentiators
The main aspects that differentiate this patent from prior art appear to be:
-
Specific method of using extended release ondansetron to treat delayed onset PONV/PDNV (2-24 hours post-surgery)
-
The claimed pharmacokinetic profile that provides therapeutic plasma levels for at least 12 hours
-
Use of a single 12-24 mg dose, which is higher than typical immediate release doses
-
Specific extended release formulations designed for this indication
Potential Strengths/Weaknesses
Strengths:
- Novel method of treating a specific clinical need (delayed PONV/PDNV)
- Pharmacokinetic parameters provide basis for non-obviousness
- Specific formulations claimed may prevent easy design-arounds
Weaknesses:
- Method of treatment claims can be challenging to enforce
- Prior art on extended release ondansetron may impact scope
- Relatively narrow focus on specific dosing/PK parameters
Conclusion
Overall, US Patent 12,005,042 appears to carve out a specific niche in using extended release ondansetron formulations to treat delayed onset post-operative and post-discharge nausea and vomiting. While there is substantial prior art on ondansetron and PONV treatment, the specific method, dosing, and pharmacokinetic profile claimed seem to be novel. The patent provides Acacia Pharma with protection for this particular use of extended release ondansetron, though the narrow focus may limit broader applicability.
Sources cited:
[1][2][3][4][5][17][20]